Lab question 1
Real Chemistry Lab
Measurement, Accuracy, and Precision
Real data from a volumetric-glassware lab. Each block is labeled so you can tell what was recorded at the bench, what was calculated from it, and what is explanation.
Part A · Pipette verification
Recorded masses and readings
10 mL beaker
- Empty mass
- 31.0163 g
- Filled mass
- 38.6512 g
- Water mass
- 7.6349 g
Volumetric pipette
- Delivered water mass
- 9.9723 g
Graduated cylinder
- Empty mass
- 39.7026 g
- Filled mass
- 49.5116 g
- Water mass
- 9.8090 g
Buret
- Delivered water mass
- 10.0324 g
- Initial reading
- 0.01 mL
- Water temperature
- 25 °C
Water density used for the documented buret calculation: 0.99705 g/mL (at the recorded 25 °C).
Buret: delivered volume and error
- Delivered volume10.0324 g ÷ 0.99705 g/mL = 10.0621 mL
- Signed volume error10.0621 mL − 10.0000 mL = +0.0621 mL
- Absolute error|+0.0621 mL| = 0.0621 mL
- Signed percent error(+0.0621 mL ÷ 10.0000 mL) × 100 = +0.621%
The positive sign means the buret delivered slightly more than the nominal 10.0000 mL.
Not established by this data
- A complete accuracy ranking of all five devices was not conclusively established.
- The final buret reading was not recorded.
- Temperatures for the other devices were not recorded, so their masses are not converted to volumes here.
- Micropipette values from Part A were unclear and are not reported.
Part B · Precision comparison
Recorded incremental masses (g)
| Device | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Volumetric pipette | 0.9843 | 0.9869 | 0.9748 | 0.9843 | 0.9898 |
| P1000 micropipette | 1.0062 | 0.9786 | 0.9741 | 0.9792 | 0.9896 |
Summary statistics
Volumetric pipette
- Mean mass
- 0.98402 g
- Sample standard deviation
- ≈ 0.00563 g
- Mass %RSD
- ≈ 0.572%
P1000 micropipette
- Mean mass
- 0.98554 g
- Sample standard deviation
- ≈ 0.01287 g
- Mass %RSD
- ≈ 1.306%
What these numbers do and do not show
The volumetric pipette had the lower %RSD, so it showed better observed mass-delivery repeatability (higher precision) in this dataset.
This does not prove greater volume accuracy. The Part B water temperatures were not recorded, so the masses cannot be reliably converted to volumes and compared with nominal values.
Key concepts
Measurement vocabulary
- Mass
- The amount of matter in a sample, measured on a balance in grams.
- Density
- Mass per unit volume (g/mL). Water density changes with temperature: 0.99705 g/mL at 25 °C.
- Delivered volume
- Mass of water delivered ÷ water density at the recorded temperature.
- Signed error
- Measured − expected. The sign shows whether a device delivered more (+) or less (−) than nominal.
- Absolute error
- The size of the error without its sign.
- Percent error
- Error ÷ expected value × 100. A measure of accuracy.
- Sample standard deviation
- The spread of repeated measurements around their mean, using n − 1 in the denominator.
- %RSD
- Standard deviation ÷ mean × 100. A measure of precision relative to the average.
Scientific integrity and corrective action
Day 1: equipment malfunction
The original balance showed unstable readings, sometimes changing by 100 g or more. The experiment was stopped. A replacement Mettler balance was located and tested in Room 466.
Day 2: measurements completed
The replacement balance was used to complete the measurements.
Why this matters
- Stop when equipment malfunctions. More readings from a faulty instrument only produce more invalid data.
- Document the problem in the lab record, even if results look reasonable.
- Take corrective action: replace the instrument and test it before use.
- Separate reliable from invalid data. Report only measurements taken with verified equipment.
Check your understanding
0 of 6 solved
Lab question 2
The buret delivered 10.0324 g of water. Using the documented water density of 0.99705 g/mL, what volume was delivered?
Lab question 3
The buret was used to deliver a nominal 10.0000 mL, and the calculated delivered volume was 10.0621 mL. What is the signed percent error?
Lab question 4
In Part B, the volumetric pipette had a mass %RSD of about 0.572%, and the P1000 micropipette about 1.306%. Which conclusion does this dataset support?
Lab question 5
Why must water temperature be recorded when converting a measured mass of water to volume?
Lab question 6